Fast forward to today - I'm having my buggy restored/refreshed and part of that was to put a center fill neck on the same tank (link to the restoration: http://www.manxclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=65&t=3371). During the tank work I got a call from Vince asking me what kind of animal died in my tank and decomposed in it? Hmmm, I know a neighbor's ferret was missing but no, that couldn't be it. Turns out that the nice sealant job I did back in 2009 had completely peeled off inside the tank. Fortunately for me it never clogged the tank filter and must have just been floating around in there for years. I never saw it when filling the tank so it's possible it was attached at some point out of sight.
I'm just providing this as a heads up for anyone with the same "good intentions" I had years ago.
New tank (2009) - can see the sealant
Dead ferret or dead Red-Kote?